What’s the point of requiring the Billing API for limited-visibility, direct-link-only apps?

Hi all,

I’d like to understand the reasoning behind a billing requirement that doesn’t seem to make sense for my setup.

My setup

  • The app is set to limited visibility - it doesn’t show up in App Store search, category pages, or search engines, and can only be installed through a direct link.
  • I only give that link to customers who have already signed up and are paying for my product outside of Shopify, and are looking to integrate Shopify.
  • I’m not trying to stop merchants from installing through Shopify. My app only has paid plans, so integrations like Shopify only become available after someone is already a paying customer.

The policy

From this thread, merchants who find an app outside Shopify can be billed through the app’s own system, and merchants who find it through Shopify must use Shopify App Billing.

Partner Support confirmed that limited-visibility apps still need Shopify App Billing because installs go through an App Store URL. They also confirmed my existing customers can stay on my own billing.

The problem

Putting those two answers together, nobody will ever be billed through Shopify App Billing for this app. Every merchant who can install it got the link from me, after already paying me externally. The only “merchant” who will ever go through Shopify billing is the app reviewer.

So I’m being asked to build and maintain a second billing system that exists only to pass review.

What I’d like to know

Is Shopify aware of this case, and is this requirement intentionally enforced for it? If so, what is it meant to accomplish when the billing path can’t be reached by a real merchant?

If I’m missing something, I’d like to hear it. As it stands, this looks like a lot of work for a code path that will only ever be used during review.

Thanks.

Thanks for raising this, @gurshanj. We recently became aware that some of the information we’ve provided about this requirement has been unclear. To clarify, the Shopify billing requirement applies to this setup.

Limited visibility changes how the app is discovered, but it remains a public app installed from a Shopify App Store URL.

Existing-customer status does not change the billing requirement after the Shopify app is installed. Charges attributable to the Shopify app or integration must use Shopify App Pricing or the Shopify Billing API. Charges for separate, non-Shopify integrations can continue through the product’s external billing system. If one bundled plan covers multiple integrations, currently the portion attributable to Shopify must still use Shopify for billing. Where the merchant signed up or received the installation link does not change which charges must use Shopify billing.

The Shopify billing path is therefore not only for app review. It applies to charges attributable to the installed Shopify integration.

See app listing visibility, App Store requirements 1.2 and 1.2.1, and the Partner Program Agreement, Part C, section 4.