@jzaz regarding the 6 months without installs..have you considered the situation when the only installs an app gets are from stores they manage themselves ?
I second this. We have two apps - one with hundreds of installs, while the other is currently used by only a handful of shops.
Supporting this as a next step, there are too much ghost company names with no actual business behind it in the app store currently
In the new Dev Dashboard, Shopify has started asking for these details, but they aren’t mandatory yet. There are now options to specify the type of registered business, upload proof of business registration, etc. I have a feeling they’ll make this mandatory pretty soon.
Love to see it. Raise the bar for merchants - help set the standard, and all that.

I believe there is a serious issue with how this new policy is being applied to existing submissions.
Our app, was submitted for App Store review before November 10 and was already waiting in the review queue. Shopify’s review team accessed our app on October 31. We waited almost two weeks without receiving any feedback, questions, or review results.
Then, on November 10, we received an automated email informing us that our app had been moved back to Draft because our organization did not meet the new submission limits.
In other words, an application that was already submitted and waiting for review was effectively removed from the queue because of a policy introduced after its submission.
We also have another published app. Now, apparently, we need to reach 10 qualifying paid installations for that app before we can resubmit new one.
How is this fair to developers who followed all the previous requirements and submitted their apps in good faith, only to have Shopify change the rules while they were waiting for review?
I understand the intention behind encouraging quality apps and genuine merchant adoption. However, these requirements should apply to new submissions made after the effective date, not applications already waiting in Shopify’s review queue.
At the very least, Shopify should grandfather all submissions made before November 10 and allow them to complete the review process under the requirements that existed when they were submitted.
We invested months of development work into our app. We are not asking for special treatment or to bypass the review process. We are simply asking Shopify to finish reviewing an application that was already in its queue.
Could someone from the App Store Review team clarify whether existing submissions will be restored or whether developers are simply expected to accept that their review process has been cancelled?
This is particularly discouraging for small independent developers trying to build serious products within the Shopify ecosystem.
Same here, months of work went into our app. We got the the finish line, celebrated our hard work, and submitted it well before this change. Then we get a notice that our app was pushed back to draft and there’s nothing we can do. All apps that were submitted before the policy change should be allowed to finish review.
Initiative is good. but it shall apply to apps Which are in Dev after the period you published it ,
I have 2 apps almost finished & now I cannot submit them suddenly
when I started working on them - there was no such restriction ,
Now I spent 2 months in building & refining them
& now I can’t submit them
I request you to please allow existing in Development apps to be submitted & you may Apply these new Rule on Apps in Dev after you launched these policies
same here I completely agree with you - I am facing the same issue with my Apps too
i spend months doing research , spent time & money
& now here we are - submission paused
@jzaz one case the 10-install rule catches: partners who already have a Built for Shopify app. My newest app (listed this month) is now blocking my next one, even though the organisation has a BFS app with 180+ installs. I’ve written it up with two suggestions here: Submission limits: count a Built for Shopify app as proven adoption