What BFCM did to app reviews last year: $14.6B in sales, but reviews rose just 9.5%

With BFCM coming up, I looked back at what the rush actually did to app reviews last year, because I’d assumed the sales spike drags a wave of reviews along with it. It mostly doesn’t.

2025 BFCM was huge for merchants - $14.6B over the weekend, and 94,900+ stores with their best sales day ever. But from Nov 1 to Dec 31 the App Store added 45,674 new reviews, only ~9.5% more than the prior two months (daily volume ~684 to ~749), with no real bump on Black Friday or Cyber Monday themselves. Activity tracked the work week, not the sales calendar - ~1,000 on weekdays, ~400 on weekends.

The top 10 categories shuffled, but not for long:

  • Discounts 6th to 4th in review volume

  • Loyalty and rewards 7th to 5th

  • Cart customization 9th to 7th

  • Product variants 4th down to 9th

By January most had reverted (Discounts back to 8th, Product variants to 5th), so the rush pulls attention toward the sales-tied apps and then fades within weeks.

What stuck with me: average time to a review is ~275 days, yet about 1 in 4 land within a day of install. Reviews seem to come in two moments - right after install, or much later once a merchant sees a result. BFCM fits neither: people aren’t installing fresh apps mid-rush, and they’re too slammed to write up a result they haven’t seen yet.

So for my own app I’m reading it as: BFCM isn’t the moment to ask for reviews, it’s the moment that creates the result worth reviewing - the ask probably lands better in January.

How do you time it? Do you push around the rush, or wait until after?

5 Likes