I recently had a very frustrating experience with a Shopify App Reviewer, and it has resulted in another app submission restriction. I have now been told that I cannot resubmit my app until November 21.
The reason for the rejection was that my app’s Account UI Extension block did not appear on the customer account page.
Here is what actually happened:
Adding a block extension to the customer account page through the Shopify Theme Editor is a very basic setup that even an ordinary Shopify merchant should be able to handle.
After adding the block, Shopify displayed a warning indicating that a menu item needed to be added to make the block accessible within the customer account page. However, the reviewer ignored this warning, did not configure the required menu item, and simply saved the changes.
Then, when checking the result, the reviewer navigated to the Profile page instead of the actual customer account page where the extension was supposed to appear.
As a result, my app was rejected.
I immediately contacted Shopify Support to explain the situation. They acknowledged the issue with the reviewer’s actions, but informed me that the appeal process would still take up to 7 days.
What I find unreasonable is that even when the mistake comes from Shopify’s own review team, the developer is the one who has to bear the consequences.
We lose valuable time, spend additional effort dealing with an issue we did not cause, and, most importantly, lose confidence in the fairness and reliability of the review process.
Developers already invest significant time and resources into building and maintaining their apps to meet Shopify’s requirements. We should not have to pay the price for mistakes made during the review process.
Has anyone else experienced something similar? How did Shopify handle your situation?