Has anyone experienced an unfair app review process like this with Shopify?

I recently had a very frustrating experience with a Shopify App Reviewer, and it has resulted in another app submission restriction. I have now been told that I cannot resubmit my app until November 21.

The reason for the rejection was that my app’s Account UI Extension block did not appear on the customer account page.

Here is what actually happened:

Adding a block extension to the customer account page through the Shopify Theme Editor is a very basic setup that even an ordinary Shopify merchant should be able to handle.

After adding the block, Shopify displayed a warning indicating that a menu item needed to be added to make the block accessible within the customer account page. However, the reviewer ignored this warning, did not configure the required menu item, and simply saved the changes.

Then, when checking the result, the reviewer navigated to the Profile page instead of the actual customer account page where the extension was supposed to appear.

As a result, my app was rejected.

I immediately contacted Shopify Support to explain the situation. They acknowledged the issue with the reviewer’s actions, but informed me that the appeal process would still take up to 7 days.

What I find unreasonable is that even when the mistake comes from Shopify’s own review team, the developer is the one who has to bear the consequences.

We lose valuable time, spend additional effort dealing with an issue we did not cause, and, most importantly, lose confidence in the fairness and reliability of the review process.

Developers already invest significant time and resources into building and maintaining their apps to meet Shopify’s requirements. We should not have to pay the price for mistakes made during the review process.

Has anyone else experienced something similar? How did Shopify handle your situation?

I have experienced something similar where the app reviewer had an internet connection problem on their end (Their screenshot shows internet issue) , and blamed my app, I had to re-submit the app and wait for almost a week

I’ve submitted my new app for review over 5 weeks ago - it’s been rejected twice (2 week delay each time) - once they were not entering data into multi-value input field correctly, and the latter they were entering incorrect data (using product name instead of product tag).

For the first issue, I improved the UX to automatically add values if they don’t click “Add” or press enter. For the second issue I’ve re-recorded the demo video to be simple and clear what should be done for testing - every step, and removed complicated or unnecessary instructions (using product tags).

I feel both issues could have been easily resolved if the reviewer had been more adept, but I’m understanding that spending all day testing new apps non-stop has to be fatiguing. My app will now be reviewed for a third time, consuming more Shopify resources, when it could have really been a one-and-done review. I’ve been vocal that the review process should be a back-and-forth exchange where clarity and feedback can be provided to the reviewer, rather than pausing the application and sending it back to the beginning just to start all over with a new reviewer weeks later.

My only suggestion is ensure your demo video contains all necessary steps for a fresh shop with a fresh theme, as this is likely how they are going to be experiencing it themselves. I thought the “Testing Instructions” text input would be the steps they follow, but it actually seems like they follow your demo video instead.

Take this with a grain of salt, as I still haven’t been successful in getting my app approved - crossing my fingers for next week.

Although there is clear evidence that the user misused a fundamental feature provided by Shopify—specifically, the ability to add blocks from an extension to the ‘Account’ page (which requires the inclusion of a menu)—they failed to set it up correctly and skipped a necessary installation step. Shopify’s support team acknowledged this, yet they refused to facilitate a direct discussion with the reviewer. Instead, they forced the app developer to bear the consequences of the reviewer’s error.

There are errors that stem from the very basics.

Can you automate this from the app?
Make it so that the merchant doesn’t have to do anything?
How much can we (devs) dumb down the button pressing so that a merchant doesn’t have to think?
I did this for one of my apps. Instead of making it a three-step process for the merchant, I made it a zero-step process. If they click on an action in the app, it takes them to the theme with the block installed, activated, and a default setting selected. The only thing the merchant has to do is save the theme (reminded by Shopify if merchant tries to exit the page)

Assume that merchants and App Store reviewers will not read your instructions?