Shopify changed the App Store submission rules this week (live Nov 10), aimed straight at low-effort listings. The store’s been pulling in around 85 new apps a day lately, and plenty of devs were sitting on dozens of listings with almost no installs.
The new rules:
Can’t list a new app unless each existing app has 10+ installs on paid, active stores
Identity verification required to submit
Cooldowns get longer with each rejected submission
No installs after 6 months, and the app gets moved back to Draft
One new app in review at a time, counted per-Partner (extra accounts won’t help)
Shopify’s framing is just “the apps you list are apps merchants use.” Hard to argue with that.
The part that nags me is the 10-install gate. Those first 10 paying installs are the hardest part of any launch, and now your second app is locked until the first one clears them - a milestone turned into a gate.
Thanks, really appreciate that. I’ve only been digging into the Shopify app market for about a year, so I’m still learning a lot. The devs here who’ve actually shipped and maintained apps see things the data alone never shows.
Your worry makes sense too. Any time a number becomes a gate, someone tries to fake the number. The “paid, active stores” part should make that harder than buying reviews, since it’d take real stores on paid plans. But I’d be curious to hear from people with more years in this than me: have you seen install schemes before, and do you think this rule actually stops them?
Hey, I hadn’t thought of this, but yep, install schemes are already a thing! They’re currently being used to game the App Store rankings by making an app appear to have more installs than it actually does.
Most fake review services offer both reviews and installs without reviews. So 10 installs without reviews would be cheap and quick to arrange. I’ve seen services offering hundreds of installs, so 10 would be nothing! The fake review sellers will already have plenty of stores ready to use, and will probably be quite happy with this new update!
And all the stores used for fake reviews are paid stores, as they have to be for their reviews to get published!
That’s a sobering point, and honestly the part I underestimated. If those stores already exist and are already on paid plans, then “paid, active stores” doesn’t add much friction for anyone willing to pay. It mostly slows down honest devs, who have to earn those 10 one by one.
It makes me think install count is just the wrong thing to gate on. Faking an install is cheap. Faking a store that keeps the app installed and actually uses it for a few months is much harder. If Shopify ever looks at retention or real usage instead of raw installs, that’s probably where it starts to bite. Do you think they have the signals to tell the difference, or is that still too hard to see from their side?
Yea! The more I’ve thought about it, the more I agree. It’s definitely just another blocker for honest devs. I do still think it’s better than nothing, though! And I appreaciate Shopify is trying!
Some sort of usage-based requirement would be much better, although I really don’t know how they’d go about implementing that!